Hi Gordon
The purpose of a user group is to discuss issues in a constructive way with other users who may have the same issues and I did object to your challenge to my logic and asking me to close the thread. This is an open discussion and other users did engage in a constructive way.
The fact remains that the Budget v Cost accounting report has some issues which I also posted on the portal you suggested.
I am not sure why you feel compelled to defend SAP, even when they get it wrong. SAP is great but it presents many challenges to users, so giving our feedback is a necessary process that will lead to the product improvement.
If I am wrong about the issue I have raised, I will be pleased to receive a valid explanation but If I am right, perhaps SAP can listen...
Thank you
Robert